Performace evaluation analysis of wireless sensor networks routing protocols in smart grids

Performace Evaluation Analysis of Wireless Sensor Networks Routing Protocols in Smart Grids

Authors

  • Carlos Deyvinson Reges Bessa Laboratório de Automação em Petróleo, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte. Natal, Brasil

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21754/tecnia.v26i1.3

Keywords:

smart grid, QoS analysis, wireless sensor networks, routing protocols

Abstract

This work aims to study which wireless sensor network routing protocol is more suitable for Smart Grids applications, through simulation of AODV protocols, AOMDV, DSDV and HTR in the NS2 simulation environment. Was simulated a network based on a residential area with 47 residences, with one node for each residence and one base station, located about 25m from the other nodes. Many parameters, such as packet loss, throughput, delay, jitter and energy consumption were tested. The network was increased to 78 and 93 nodes in order to evaluate the behavior of the protocols in larger networks. The tests proved that the HTR is the routing protocol that has the best results in performance and second best in energy consumption. The DSDV had the worst performance according to the tests.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Garrity T F 2008 Getting smart IEEE Power Energy Mag 6(2), pp 38–45

[2] Torres J A, Arias D, Miralles R 2009 Applicability of wireless communication technologies for measurement in the denise electrical distribution network 20th International Conference On Electricity Distribution Praga, pp.1-4

[3] ArdakaniS P, Padget J, de Vos M 2014 HRTS: A hierarchical reactive time synchronization protocol for wireless sensor networks Social informatics and telecommunications engineering pp 47-62

[4] Wategaonka N, Deshpande S 2012 Characteriza-tion of reliability in WSN 2012 World Congress On Information And Communication Technologies pp 970-975

[5] Mukhopadhyay S C and Huang R Y M 2008 Advan-cements in Modeling, Design Issues, Fabrication and Practical Applications Springer-Verlag:Heidelberg chapter 11 pp 221-245

[6] Yerra P and et al. 2011 WSN based power moni-toring in smart grids Seventh International Confe-rence On Intelligent Sensors, Sensor Networks And Information Processing pp 401-406

[7] Gharavi H and Hu Multigate B 2011 Communi-cation Network for Smart Grid Proceedings of the IEEE

[8] Oliveira D M, Semente F S, Correia de Melo R, Ortiz T A and Salazar A 2014 QoS Analysis of Rou-ting Protocols in Wireless Sensor Networks in the Monitoring of Wind Farms

[9] Toledo F 2012 Desvendando as Redes Elétricas Inteligentes Smart Grid Handbook Brasport pp 336

[10] Hong X, Xu K and Gerla M 2002 Scalable routing protocols for mobile ad hoc networks 16(4) pp11-21

[11] Johnson D B, Maltz D A and Broch J 2001 DSR: the dynamic source routing protocol for multihop wireless ad hoc networks Ad hoc networking pp 139-172

[12] Perkins C E and Royer E M 1999 Ad-hoc on-de-mand distance vector routing Mobile Computing Systems and Applications pp 90-100

[13] Singh Chadha M and Joon R 2012 Sandeep Simu-lation and Comparison of AODV, DSR and AOMDV Routing Protocols in MANETs. International Journal of Soft Computing and Engineering

[14] Niu J, Cheng L, Gu Y, Shu L, and Das S K 2014 R3E: Reliable Reactive Routing Enhancement for Wireless Sensor Networks IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics 10(1) pp 784-794

[15] Nadeem J, Mohammad S N, Latif K, Qasim U, Khan Z A and Khan M A 2013 HEER: hybrid energy efficient reactive protocol for wireless sensor ne-tworks Electronics, Communications and Photonics Conference (SIECPC) Saudi International pp 1-4

[16] Clausen T and Jacquet P 2003 Optimized link state routing protocol (OLSR) Project Hipercom:INRIA pp 1 -56

[17] Perkins C E, Watson T J, Bhagwat P 1994 Highly dynamic destinationsequenced distance-vector routing (DSDV) for mobile computers SIGCOMM '94 Proceedings of the conference on Communica-tions architectures, protocols and applications pp 234-244

[18]Sajid M, Khan K, Quasim U, Khan Z A, Tariq S and Javaid N 2015 A new linear cluster handling (LCH) technique toward’s energy efficiency in linear WSNs IEEE 29th International Conferenceon advanced information networking and application pp389-393

[19] Cordeiro C and Agrawal D 2002 Mobile ad hoc networking XX Simpósio Brasileiro de Redes de Computadores pp 125-186[20] Bilel N, Ye-Qiong S 2007 Performance Analysis and improvement of ZigBee routing protocol 7th IFAC Conference on Fieldbuses and Networks in Industrial and Embedded Systems IFAC Proceedings 40(22) pp 99-206

[21] Chiang C 1997 Routing in clustered multihop, mobile wireless networks with fading channel IEEE SICON'97 pp 197-217

[22] Heinzelman W, Chandrakasan A and Balakrish-nan H 2000 Energy-efficient communication proto-col for wireless microsensor networks Proceedings of the 33rd International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS '00) pp 1 -10

[23] Ardakani S P, Padget J, de Vos M 2014 HRTS: A hierarchical reactive time synchronizationprotocol for wireless sensor networks Social informaticsand telecommunications engineering pp47-62

[24] Khan K, Sajid M, Mahmood S, Khan Z A, Qasim U and Javaid N 2015 (LEACH)2: Combining LEACH with Linearly Enhanced Approach for Cluster Handling in WSNs 2015 IEEE 29th International Conference on Advanced Information Networking and Applications (AINA) pp 394-399

[25] Yu Y, Govindan R and Estrin D 2001 Geogra-phical and Energy Aware Routing a recursive datadissemination protocol for wireless sensor networ-ks pp 2-11

[26] Macedo D F, Macedo P F, Correia L H A, Santos A L, Loureiro A F, Nogueira J M S 2006 Um pro-tocolo de roteamento para redes ad hoc com QoSbaseado no controle da potência de transmissão 24 Simpósio Brasileiro de Redes de Computadores pp 605-620

[27] Cheng D, Song Y, Mao Y and Wang X 2014 LD-DP:A Location-based Directed Diffusion Routing Protocol For Smart Home Sensor Network 2nd In-ternational Conference on Systems and Informatics (ICSAI 2014) pp 510-514

[28] Nikaein N, Labiod H and Bonnet C 2000 DDR –Distributed dynamic routing algorithm for mobile ad hoc networks Mobile and Ad Hoc IEEE Networ-king and Computing MobiHOC First Annual Works-hop pp 19-27

[29] ZigBee Alliance 2007 ZigBeespecification stan-dard

[30] Chaudhari P J 2014 Stealthier Attack on Zone routing Protocol in Wireless Sensor Network Fourth International Conference on Communication Systems and Network Technologies pp 734-738

[31] de Oliveira M 2015 FTE-LEACH: Um Protocolo Energeticamente Eficiente e Tolerante a Falhas Aplicado às Redes Industriais de Sensores sem Fio Tese (Doutorado) Preprint pp 104

[32] Vakulya G and Simon G 2012 Energy-efficient and reliable round-robin TDMA for wireless sensor networks Instrumentation and Measurement Tech-nology Conference (I2MTC) pp 1179-1183

[33] Zhang Y, Chowdhury A A and Koval D O 2010 Probabilistic wind energy modeling in electric generation system reliability assessment Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Technical Conferen-ce (I&CPS) pp 1-8

Downloads

Published

2016-06-01

How to Cite

[1]
C. D. Reges Bessa, “Performace evaluation analysis of wireless sensor networks routing protocols in smart grids: Performace Evaluation Analysis of Wireless Sensor Networks Routing Protocols in Smart Grids”, TECNIA, vol. 26, no. 1, pp. 17–26, Jun. 2016.

Issue

Vol. 26 No. 1 (2016)

Section

Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2016 TECNIA

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Articles published by TECNIA can be shared under the international Creative Commons license: CC BY 4.0. Permissions beyond this scope can be inquired via email at tecnia@uni.edu.pe.